Employing the Payback Framework to Assess Implementation Science Research Utilization: Lessons From the USAID's PEPFAR HIV/AIDS Implementation Science Awards

Castor, Delivette; Kimmel, Allison L.; McFall, Allison; Padian, Nancy; Yansaneh, Aisha; Wiant, Sarah; Sandison, Sarah; Holmes, Charles; Lucas, Rachel; Stanton, David; Goosby, Eric; Kottiri, Benny

Background: Stakeholders question whether implementation science (IS) is successful in conducting rigorous science that expedites the inclusion of health innovations into policies and accelerates the pace and scale of health service delivery into clinical and public health practice. Using the Payback Framework (PF) for research utilization (RU), we assessed the impact of USAID's IS investment on a subset of studies examining HIV prevention, care, and treatment.

Setting: Selected USAID-funded IS awards implemented between 2012 and 2017 in 9 sub-Saharan African countries.

Methods: A modified version of a RU framework, the PF, was applied to 10 USAID-funded IS awards. A semistructured, self-administered/interviewer-administered questionnaire representing operational items for the 5 categories of the modified PF was used to describe the type and to quantify the level of payback achieved. The raw score was tallied within and across the 5 PF categories, and the percentage of “payback” achieved by category was tabulated. Distribution of payback scores was summarized by tertiles.

Results: Knowledge production had the highest level of payback (75%), followed by benefits to future research (70%), benefits to policy (45%), benefits to health and the health system (18%), and broader economic benefits (5%).

Conclusions: All awards achieved some level of knowledge production and benefits to future research, but translation to policy and programs was low and variable. We propose the use of policy, health system, and economic monitoring indicators of RU throughout the research process to increase IS studies' impact on health practice, programs, and policy.

December 30, 2019
Year of publication
Resource types
Journal and research articles
HIV implementation science, investment, Learning Evaluation and Research (LER)

Similar Resources

An important collection of articles focused on infant medical male circumcision as an approach to sustain the HIV prevention gains made from adult voluntary medical male circumcision (VMMC). The ten articles in this collection offer insight into a few country experiences with introduction of…

For prevention of HIV, early infant male circumcision (EIMC) needs to be scaled up in countries with high HIV prevalence. Routine EIMC will maintain the HIV prevention gains anticipated from current adult male circumcision initiatives.

The government of the Kingdom of Swaziland recognizes that it must urgently scale up HIV prevention interventions, such as voluntary medical male circumcision (VMMC). Swaziland has adopted a 2-phase approach to male circumcision scale-up.

The World Health Organization and the Joint United Nations Programme on HIV/AIDS recommend early infant male circumcision (EIMC) as a component of male circumcision programs in countries with high HIV prevalence and low circumcision rates.

Sexual and reproductive health and rights have gained prominence in the HIV response. The role of sexual and reproductive health in underpinning a successful approach to HIV prevention, treatment, care, and services has increasingly been recognized.

The Primary Health Care Performance Initiative (PHCPI) is a new partnership that brings together country policymakers, health system managers, practitioners, advocates and other development partners to catalyze improvements in primary health care (PHC) in low- and middle-income countries through…

The AIDSFree Guidance Database is your one-stop shop for national HIV testing and treatment policies from PEPFAR priority countries.

Clinical trials are more and more delocalized to low- and middle-income countries (LMICs), either for reasons of external validity (to test new interventions in various epidemiological settings), or for convenience reasons (lower costs, easier review and easier availability of subjects), or for…

The female sex worker (FSW) respondent-driven sampling (RDS) study conducted in 7 regions on Tanzania is the first biological and behavioural surveillance study of its kind in Tanzania to be conducted in a large scale geographical area.